C
A
T
E
G
O
R
I
E
S

&

R
E
C
E
N
T

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps

Posted by tigerhawkvok on October 13, 2009 23:56 in evolution , religion , anti-science , creationists

First, due diligence, as this entry in the series is brought to you by Bill O'Reilly:

Oh, Bill. Dare I count the ways you are flawed in your arguments?

  • A gap in scientific data should be explained as either "insufficient evidence" or a scientific conjecture. To quote Dawkins, "It's a most of extraordinary piece of warped logic to say because science can't fill in a particular gap you're going throw in your lot with Christianity." If it should be filled-in with myths, why not the Cthulhu mythos, Invisible Pink Unicorn, Greek Pantheon, Egyptian Pantheon, Norse Pantheon, or druidic theism instead of Christian mythos?
  • You fail Godwin's Law.
  • You realize you spoke more than your interviewee, right?
  • You realize Jesus probably looked more like a middle eastern guy, right?
  • Your theology fails the self-sacrificing pacifist test when you look at religious wars on the behalf of Christianity, and the opulence of the Vatican.
  • Saying there are more X than Y therefore what X believes is true is a fallacy.

I think when I return to SD I might create a powerpoint slideshow to showcase these "alternate viewpoints", and include a few (ie, soup, clay-assisted, RNA-world) scientific hypotheses thrown in for fun. Take it from universe creation to first autoreplicable form.

To drive the point home: gaps in scientific understanding, no matter your level of scientific understanding, should never be replaced with psuedoscience or mythology in its place

Here's a nice YouTube clip that's not quite related, but discusses the spread of misinformation by the Discovery Institute

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.



Trackbacks

Xtreme Antler Review

Xtreme Antler Review | 09/02/2015 11:32

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps | The Dichotomous Trekkie 2.0

Jeff Halevy

Jeff Halevy | 04/02/2015 11:08

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps | The Dichotomous Trekkie 2.0

Createurs de Luxe

Createurs de Luxe | 23/01/2015 00:54

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps | The Dichotomous Trekkie 2.0

T Advance Review

T Advance Review | 03/01/2015 23:11

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps | The Dichotomous Trekkie 2.0

Freedom Mentor Reviews

Freedom Mentor Reviews | 07/12/2014 15:37

Wrongheaded Creationists 3: Gaps, gaps, gaps | The Dichotomous Trekkie 2.0